StoryboardAI Engineering

Asking first

Pausing before an action that sends something out or cannot be undone, and waiting for a person to say yes.

What is asking a person first?

Reading and drafting are safe to get wrong. Sending an email, paying, deleting or publishing are not. For those, a well-built agent stops and shows the person exactly what it is about to do.

The check is made by ordinary code in the harness, not by the model, so the model cannot talk its way past it. The person can approve, change or refuse.

Asking about everything trains people to click yes without reading. The skill is in asking only when it matters, and making the request specific enough to judge at a glance.

A pause, and a person, before anything irreversible.Step 1: An action that cannot be undone. Step 2: The harness pauses. Step 3: A person sees the real action. Step 4: Approved: it runs.1An action thatcannot be undone2The harness pauses3A person sees thereal action4Approved: it runs
A pause, and a person, before anything irreversible.

Why does asking a person first matter?

Some actions cannot be taken back: sending an email, paying money, deleting a record. A model's confidence is no guide to whether such an action is right. Pausing for a person at those moments keeps a human in charge of what matters, while leaving the assistant free to do everything harmless on its own.

How does asking a person first work?

  1. Every action the assistant can take is sorted, in code, into free, ask first or never.
  2. When an ask-first action comes up, the harness pauses.
  3. It shows the person the real action: the actual recipient, text and amount.
  4. The person approves, edits or refuses.
  5. Only then does the action run, and the decision is recorded.

When should you use asking a person first?

Use it when

  • An action cannot be undone
  • It moves money or leaves your system
  • There is not yet a record showing the assistant gets this kind of thing right

Think twice when

  • The action only reads, or is trivially undone
  • Asking so often that people approve without looking

Where does asking a person first sit in a real system?

The pause is implemented in the harness, at the point where a tool is about to run. The rule about which actions need it lives in code, never in the prompt.

What goes wrong with asking a person first?

  • Showing the model's description of the action in place of the action itself.
  • Asking about everything, which trains people to click yes.
  • Letting the model decide whether approval is needed.

What does asking a person first look like in practice?

A browser agent reaches a button marked "Confirm and pay". The harness holds the click and shows the person the real screenshot with the total read from the page: $54 against a limit of $60. The person approves, and the click is carried out.

Watch it happen

These stories show asking first at work, one step at a time.